Platform Evaluation Scorecard

Evaluate competing platforms across six dimensions of operational fit.

Platforms under evaluation

Name two to four platforms to compare. These can be specific products, vendor proposals, or architectural alternatives.

Evaluation context

The analysis uses these answers to interpret your scores. The criteria and rubrics stay the same whatever you choose here.

Each dimension includes evaluation criteria and a scoring rubric. Adjust weights, score each platform, and generate a comparative analysis.

1 Fails requirements 2 Below requirements 3 Meets requirements 4 Exceeds 5 Best in class
Weight

Score the platform's native data model against your constituent record structure, gift processing requirements, and relationship tracking needs. If the CRM's advancement data model is weak, you pay for more custom development in each later phase. Evaluate against your own operational workflows.

Evaluation criteria
  • Constituent record structure: individual, organization, and household relationships with proper cardinality
  • Gift processing model: pledges, pledge payments, recurring gifts, planned giving vehicles, gift-in-kind
  • Soft credit and matching gift handling with accurate aggregation logic
  • Fund, campaign, appeal, and designation hierarchies with rollup reporting
  • Relationship tracking across overlapping affiliations: board, volunteer, alumni, parent, donor, patient
Scoring rubric
1
Core constituent and gift objects require custom development; no native advancement model
2
Basic contact and opportunity model; gift processing requires significant extension; limited relationship types
3
Standard advancement model covering individual giving, pledge management, and basic fund structures; customization needed for complex giving vehicles
4
Comprehensive model with planned giving instruments, multi-entity soft credits, and hierarchical fund/campaign structures built in
5
Purpose-built advancement data model with stewardship tracking, prospect management, committee/volunteer tracking, and extensible entity framework

Common evaluation mistakes

  • Rating "customizable" the same as "already built." A platform that can be configured to handle planned giving is not equivalent to one that ships with planned giving objects, workflows, and reporting.
  • Evaluating the data model in isolation from reporting. A data model that stores gift data correctly but cannot aggregate it for campaign progress reporting without custom views is incomplete.
  • Ignoring the household model. Organizations that report on household giving need a platform that models households natively. Otherwise staff manage household relationships by hand.
Weight
Weight
Weight
Weight
Weight

Comparative analysis

The analysis uses your scores and evaluation context.

We provide technical counsel during platform evaluation, selection, and transition.

Start a conversation